Translate to your language:)

Wednesday, 27 December 2017

"Asian Forex traders attracted to Bitcoin because of its higher volatility" sounds nonsense only to me?

Some articles have said Asian Forex traders, so called Mr/Mrs.Watanabe symbolically, have been shifting from fiat FX trading to crypto FX trading, betting on BTCUSD, ETHJPY, LTCEUR ...  It is also said that those traders are attracted to higher volatility compared to the lower volatility in fiat FX market. It would be a true fact that crypto's volatility is higher than fiat's one. The volatility of BTCUSD could be about 10 times more than the volatility of GBPUSD for last 6 months.

Well, if you are more experienced traders, you would agree that the volatility is not (only) a reason to choose underlying assets. Before making conclusion which of fiat FX or crypto FX are more reasonable underlyings, let's take a look some fundamental data. Here is a comparison between BTCUSD and GBPUSD in Bid/Ask quotes and the spread, observed at one of regulated brokers today.
Quotes: BTCUSD and GBPUSD
It tells that the spread/quote is about 65 times in BTCUSD against GBPUSD. In case of investing USD 10,000 for each BTCUSD and GBPUSD respectively, the immediate cost for BTCUSD is about USD 98 while one for GBPUSD is about USD 1.5.
Some Watanabes would claim that they expect higher volatility driving their profit and absorbing the cost. So let's take another measure of the expected profit in case of one-sigma moved to a favour direction. Using daily volatility for last 6 months, it is estimated below.
P/L by one-sigma up
Oops, BTCUSD performs more than GBPUSD even after the expensive cost. (Gap = USD 365)
It is the fact, but does it mean we should invest in crypto FX rather than fiat FX?

The brokers usually allows investors to leverage, so see how much investment will bring same return in fiat FX as crypto FX. It is not a big deal. In this case, if you leverage only about 8.7 times on the fiat position, you will get same returns by one-sigma up.
Leveraged on the fiat position
Brokers offers more leverage on fiat FX while far small leverage is allowed on crypto FX, so you could only put your money USD 10,000 at the account.

Ok, but some might argue that BTCUSD performs same as GBPUSD but does not need such leverage. We took the case for upside this time, but how about the downside risk?
Under the same condition, but in case of one-sigma down, the P/L is estimated below:
P/L by one-sigma down, leveraged on the fiat position
You lose USD 147 more from BTCUSD position while both BTCUSD and GBPUSD have same returns from one-sigma up. This is naturally because the Bid/Ask spread is wider in BTCUSD.

Relatively lower volatility at fiat FX can be compensated by just 8.7 times leverage. The downside risk is smaller in fiat FX than crypto FX, to expect same upside. If you do not have very specific preference, it seems be more reasonable to trade fiat FX rather than crypto FX, doesn't it?

I have no intention to stop Mr/Mrs.Watanabes trading crypto FX, but probably worth to rethink about it.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.